50 Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Christians

Cheerful ethnic females wearing warm sweaters and red Santa hats sitting on fluffy white carpet near decorated Christmas tree and chatting merrily

Christmas is a wonderful time to celebrate the birth of Jesus, spend time with family, enjoy festive traditions, and create meaningful memories with friends and loved ones. One simple way to bring laughter and conversation to your Christmas gathering is by playing a Christmas Would You Rather game.

These Christmas Would You Rather questions for Christians combine festive fun, faith, Bible knowledge, Christmas traditions, and thoughtful choices. They are perfect for Christian families, Sunday school classes, youth groups, church Christmas parties, Bible study gatherings, and holiday game nights.

Whether you’re looking for funny Christmas questions, faith-based questions, questions for kids, or conversation starters for adults, this collection has something for everyone.

Simply read each question aloud and let everyone choose which option they would prefer. Some questions are silly, some are meaningful, and others might spark interesting conversations about faith and the true meaning of Christmas.

Christmas Would You Rather Questions About Faith

These questions focus on Christian faith, the meaning of Christmas, Jesus’ birth, and biblical themes.

  1. Would you rather spend Christmas morning reading the story of Jesus’ birth or singing Christmas hymns?
  2. Would you rather visit Bethlehem during the night Jesus was born or witness the angels announcing His birth to the shepherds?
  3. Would you rather hear Mary tell the story of Jesus’ birth or listen to Joseph explain how God spoke to him in dreams?
  4. Would you rather attend a midnight Christmas service or a Christmas morning church service?
  5. Would you rather memorize Luke 2 or Matthew 1 this Christmas?
  6. Would you rather spend Christmas helping people in need or organizing a Christmas celebration for your church?
  7. Would you rather sing your favorite Christmas hymn with a choir or listen to a beautiful solo?
  8. Would you rather spend an entire Christmas day discussing the Bible or sharing testimonies of God’s goodness?
  9. Would you rather receive a handwritten prayer from a friend or a handwritten Bible verse?
  10. Would you rather celebrate Christmas with a simple meal and prayer or a large family gathering filled with laughter?

Christmas Would You Rather Questions About the Bible

These questions are great for Bible study groups, Christian trivia games, Sunday school, and family gatherings. They encourage players to think about the biblical Christmas story.

11. Would you rather be one of the shepherds who first heard the news of Jesus’ birth or one of the wise men who followed the star?

12. Would you rather see the angel Gabriel appear to Mary or witness the heavenly host praising God?

13. Would you rather travel to Bethlehem with Mary and Joseph or journey with the wise men from the East?

14. Would you rather bring gold to baby Jesus or bring frankincense?

15. Would you rather have been present at the manger when Jesus was born or witnessed His presentation at the temple?

16. Would you rather hear the prophecy of Isaiah about Jesus’ birth or hear the angel announce His birth to the shepherds?

17. Would you rather spend one day with Mary or one day with Joseph?

18. Would you rather be a shepherd watching your sheep when the angel appeared or a wise man discovering the star?

19. Would you rather have the ability to ask the wise men about their journey or ask the shepherds about the night Jesus was born?

20. Would you rather read the Christmas story from Luke’s Gospel or Matthew’s Gospel every Christmas?

Funny Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Christians

These lighthearted questions are perfect for family Christmas parties, youth groups, and church gatherings where everyone wants to laugh.

21. Would you rather sing every Christmas carol in church with the wrong lyrics or accidentally sing too loudly during every quiet prayer?

22. Would you rather wear a Christmas sweater with a giant nativity scene or wear a Santa hat to every church service for a week?

23. Would you rather eat Christmas dinner with the shepherds or share a meal with the wise men?

24. Would you rather have a Christmas tree decorated entirely with Bible verses or a house filled with angel decorations?

25. Would you rather be responsible for leading Christmas worship or organizing the church Christmas dinner?

26. Would you rather have to sing “Silent Night” every time someone asks you a question or say “Merry Christmas” every five minutes?

27. Would you rather have a Christmas party where everyone sings hymns or one where everyone plays Bible games?

28. Would you rather accidentally fall asleep during a Christmas sermon or forget the words to your favorite Christmas hymn while singing in front of everyone?

29. Would you rather have a snowstorm on Christmas Eve or have your Christmas lights stop working on Christmas morning?

30. Would you rather eat only Christmas cookies for one day or only Christmas leftovers for three days?

Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Christian Families

These questions are ideal for family gatherings and can be enjoyed by children, parents, grandparents, and relatives of all ages.

31. Would you rather spend Christmas at home with your family or travel somewhere special with your loved ones?

32. Would you rather decorate the Christmas tree together or bake Christmas cookies together?

33. Would you rather have everyone share their favorite Bible verse at Christmas dinner or share their favorite Christmas memory?

34. Would you rather open presents on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?

35. Would you rather have a Christmas dinner with all your relatives or a quiet Christmas with your closest family?

36. Would you rather spend Christmas volunteering at a homeless shelter or visiting elderly people who are alone?

37. Would you rather have a family Christmas Bible quiz or a family Christmas scavenger hunt?

38. Would you rather watch a Christmas movie together or read the Christmas story together?

39. Would you rather give everyone handmade gifts or buy everyone a thoughtful present?

40. Would you rather have a Christmas celebration without phones or a Christmas celebration where everyone shares pictures throughout the day?

Meaningful Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Christians

These questions encourage deeper conversations about generosity, gratitude, faith, kindness, and the true meaning of Christmas.

41. Would you rather give a gift to someone who cannot afford Christmas presents or receive your dream Christmas gift?

42. Would you rather spend Christmas encouraging someone who feels lonely or helping a family struggling financially?

43. Would you rather have the opportunity to share the Gospel with one person at Christmas or encourage ten people who are struggling with their faith?

44. Would you rather spend Christmas serving others or spend the day resting and reflecting on God’s blessings?

45. Would you rather receive a gift that reminds you of God’s faithfulness or a gift that helps you grow spiritually?

46. Would you rather forgive someone before Christmas or ask someone to forgive you before Christmas?

47. Would you rather spend Christmas praying for people around the world or praying for your family and friends?

48. Would you rather give away most of your Christmas gifts to people in need or spend your Christmas budget helping a struggling family?

49. Would you rather spend an entire Christmas day thanking God for every blessing or praying for every challenge you are facing?

50. Would you rather make Christmas more about giving, serving, and loving others or focus on creating the most memorable celebration possible?

How to Play Christmas Would You Rather With Your Church or Family

Playing Christmas Would You Rather is simple, and you don’t need any special equipment.

  1. Gather everyone together in a circle or around the Christmas table.
  2. Read one question aloud.
  3. Give everyone a few seconds to choose between the two options.
  4. Let participants explain why they made their choice.
  5. Encourage everyone to participate, including children and quieter guests.
  6. Continue until you’ve answered all the questions or run out of time.

You can make the game more interactive by asking players to move to one side of the room for their choice, raise their hands, or vote using Christmas-colored cards.

For church groups, you can also use the questions as icebreakers before a Christmas Bible study, party, or fellowship activity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are good Christmas Would You Rather questions for Christians?

Good questions combine Christmas traditions, Bible stories, Christian faith, family activities, generosity, and humor. Questions about the shepherds, wise men, Mary, Joseph, Christmas worship, and helping others are especially suitable for Christian gatherings.

Can children play Christmas Would You Rather?

Yes! Many of these questions are family-friendly and suitable for children. For younger kids, choose questions about Christmas gifts, decorations, Christmas songs, Bible characters, and family traditions.

How do you play Christmas Would You Rather at church?

Read each question aloud and let church members choose between the two options. You can divide the room into teams, have participants move to different sides, or simply let everyone vote. It works well as an icebreaker during Christmas parties and youth group gatherings.

What makes Christian Christmas Would You Rather questions different?

Christian Christmas Would You Rather questions include themes related to Jesus’ birth, Bible stories, faith, prayer, worship, generosity, forgiveness, and the meaning of Christmas, while still keeping the game fun and engaging.

Christmas is a season of joy, gratitude, generosity, and celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ. These 50 Christmas Would You Rather questions are a simple way to bring people closer together, encourage meaningful conversations, and add laughter to your holiday celebrations.

Use them with your family, church friends, Sunday school students, youth group, or Christmas party guests. You may be surprised by the answers people give!

Merry Christmas, and may your holiday be filled with faith, love, laughter, and God’s blessings.

Abram Mitchell
Abram Mitchell

Abram Mitchell has been studying the Bible and Christian faith for over 10 years. His writing is shaped by a deep personal faith and a desire to make Scripture accessible to everyday believers. Through Bible Is Life, he has written over 900 articles on Bible verses, character studies, prayers, and Christian living — helping readers understand God's Word in practical, meaningful ways. He is passionate about bringing clarity to Scripture and encouraging believers in their daily walk with Christ.

Articles: 1282